Board Thread:The Flash discussions/@comment-4036559-20181010183851/@comment-2054358-20181018035429

There are a lot of live-action shows that do crazy concepts. There are live-action comedies that are critically acclaimed. If the Incredibles had a live-action remake with the same script, the remake could still be a box office success with people praising it. Okay, as a remake it could be compared as inferior to the original. But in an alternate timeline where Pixar decided to make The Incredibles live-action, it could make the same amount of money as our time that has the animated Incredibles. Maybe? Pixar doesn't exactly do live-action. Actually, maybe an Incredibles live-action movie wouldn't have the same charm as the animated one. How would you get an actor in the same shape as Mr. Incredible? A girl would have to starve herself for the role of Violet. Frozone is a caricature of Samuel L. Jackson but his head is not shaped right. But even if it's not the Incredibles, a live-action super hero family movie with a super baby could still be successful if done right. And whether a movie would be successful or fail is not predictable. Just look at Venom who managed to make it's budget back without Spider-Man.