User blog comment:Lonearch/Arrow Season 5 Theories/THoughts/@comment-27700324-20160704035704/@comment-28501280-20160705044224

Actually I think the Black Siren theory is great. I don't necessarily think that they should bring Earth-1 back. The only reason the would would be for the fans and the ratings (since both are dropping). I think that Black Siren would be a totally interesting dynamic. The creators left her death with mystery because they want fan theories. Laurel didn't have a the strongest arc is season two but Katie Cassidy won an award for it. It was great, dark, realistic and necessary. I think that she had a strong arc in season three but got pushed to the side in season four because frankly, there wasn't enough room. But her fan base was rising. In a recent poll, a website asked DC tv fans to got for their favorite superhero (from Arrow, Flash, Legends, Supergirl and Lucifer). Black Canary won with 33,000 votes. Fans want her back. No I don't agree with the resurrection theory. It would destroy the devastation of death. But the Black Siren theory (even if she isn't a hero) is a good one. Team Arrow and Flash are close so they're going to find out about her. They killed any potential Black Canary had. Yes it does not have to follow comic storylines. But it should draw inspiration from them. Dinah Laurel Lance is a huge character. She is inspiration to females and addicts everywhere. In her appearance in Green Arrow Rebirth, the comic book sold out. People want her because she is iconic. And they need to have her back in some form. Arrow isn't going anywhere soon. But it's reception and ratings are. The finale received a 3.8 from IGN. I read the comments, and it was full of thousands of comments of hate for Arrow. Arrow failed Laurel Lance, so why not start over with Black Siren? She doesn't have to become a hero, but it would be so interesting to her interactions with the Team. So many people have been hating on Arrow this season. They need to do something because their fans are dropping faster than the dead birds in Cisco's vision.