Board Thread:Supergirl discussions/@comment-31722073-20190520131713/@comment-31722073-20190618172458

Xandermcc wrote: Season 3 of Legends had some great moments, but i don't think it was the best one of the whole Arrowverse. I think Season 2 deserves that spot.

Supergirl balancing it's large cast is a hard move cause CBS already left them with a cast that was largely disconnected from each other in terms of the plot. Cause that is how they do shows. Cat, Jimmy, and Winn were part of Kara's Catco life which was largely disconnected from the D.E.O part of things with Alex, J'onn, and Kara. With Lucy Lane being the only bridge connecting them at the end along with a brief appearance from Barry Allen. Season 2 changed that by adding Winn to the D.E.O side of things, and replacing Cat with Mon-El. However they opened up new problems when making Jimmy a superhero didn't really change the fact that he was disconnected from Kara's plot. They even disconnected Alex by involving her with Maggie who they had so disconnected to everything Supergirl did. Season 3 brought everyone back together into one central plot point of stopping Reign, but Jimmy was still sidelined and even Alex when they went to Argo. Finally Season 4 fixed it all by giving everyone a threat that both the human and alien protagonist can get against evenly. Where they are all connected. That was the main key. While I disagree on the quality of Season 2 (I agree it was really good, but I didn't have that "holy crap this is amazing" moment until Season 3, I imagine I'll enjoy it more whenever I end up rewatching the show), I wasn't trying to say that Season 3 was the best of the Arrowverse, I meant that Season 2 of Arrow, Season 3 of Legends and Supergirl this year were the best seasons, though not necessarily in that order.