User blog comment:You Know I am Awesome/Identity of The Man in the Mask/@comment-6284741-20160504164427

That is a very entertaining possibility. The only possibility I think is that it might be E1 Eddie/Jay Garrick/The Flash. This is my original theory i posted on the "Versus Zoom" discussion board (and i believe it's either this theory or yours by the way) : 18:59, April 20, 2016Quote More
 * I doubt it would be but hear me out guys. We saw Barry go to Earth-Supergirl and then 1 second later come back. Who's to say this can't happen with an Earth-2 breach? We saw Eddie get sucked in the Singularity, obviously teasing that something is going to happen concerning him. We also know Earth-2 has advanced technology. So what if he appeared there and then they used this to revive him. Now it also makes sense now to think that "Past-Zoom"/The Flash (that got killed by "Older Zoom") is not the real Jay Garrick. I believe he stole his name. What if Eddie got revived, and then was affected somehow by the Earth-2 Particle Accelerator and became the real Jay Garrick. As for why Eobard Thawne is still a time remnant, I would say that all of this threw Eddie's future so off of course that he never had children and so a time remnant was the only way for Eobard Thawne/Reverse-Flash to still exist. Time Remnants are really confusing too. I kind of see the Speed Force it as like a force of nature, like gravity. And it is doing what keeps Time most stable. So yeah, either version of Zoom kidnapped Eddie/Jay and is holding him prisoner. So yeah, that's the million dollar theory.
 * Bo-Katan I forgot to add that in this theory eddie appeared there before the particle accelerator exploded and energy leaked underground.