Board Thread:Arrow discussions/@comment-9346948-20161208015315/@comment-27700324-20170119211857

Purple500 wrote: Kaestal wrote: The name calling you keep slinging out despite being a huge part of the issue (I won't claim innocence in this either) just proves that the two (three?) of you aren't better than one another.

The general idea I have gotten from this debacle is that Doctor230 and Purple want E-2 Laurel to turn good or E-1 Laurel to return from the dead.

Meanwhile, Xander (and myself) don't see either thing as a good idea due to either the reasoning being incredibly poor on the Black Siren turns good point, which if they make her part of the team is basically saying "All that horrible crap you did is okay" and the "Death has no consequence" issue that would result in Laurel-1's return.

We can stop debating this now, the points have been thrown onto the table. It has gotten old. I never said I was and in any case I don't know what's going to happen so let's just enjoy the show and see where everything goes. I think black siren will join or least co-operate with team arrow and no one has any control of that so just let it happen despite the awful things she has done. I will say one thing, you are right this has gotten old. whatever happens, who ever does become the black canary, they just better do it now because really laurel shouldn't have been killed off in the first place. enough characters have already, why more? I've said this before in another post and I'll say this again referring to laurel, this is the arrowverse- there are aliens, magic, time travel and so on. does anyone really find it so hard to believe that someone could be killed and somehow be resurrected from the dead, my god it's not like it hasn't happened before. something people should also ask is how saving Laurel from her death would have created some kind time aberration. it would affect and hurt everyone in her life (friends, family and loved ones) but really that's it. Well the problem with time travel is that it makes sure that the event never happened to begin with. So all the scenes in S5 mentioning Laurel wouldn't happen if time travel changed things. That is the real flaw with that. Also when was it shown that she was teaming up with team arrow? I thought the promo showed her trying to kill them all.