Board Thread:Arrow discussions/@comment-27700324-20181113045859/@comment-9346948-20181115061444

CarverSindile wrote: I was told by TimeShade that I couldn't add Batman to Talia al Ghul because it's speculation according to him or her (I say him or her since I don't know TimeShade's gender. I just never asked as far as I can remember). But I've seen several articles that say otherwise. From me reading the article, I'm getting the gist that it's not speculation. Multiple articles citing the demon episode say he exists and that is who Talia was talking about when she said old foe aka Batman. So either Timeshade is wrong and every article I've read so far is right. Or he or she thinks they are right and everybody else is wrong. You are welcome to come and explain it to me Timeshade. It's about context. These sites are just saying that based on the comics. There aren't any official confirmation whatsoever. Articles need to be edited as if you're completely oblivious to the comics. You can't just say something because comics. So many things on the show are completely different. A for could literally be anyone.