Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-16581186-20161115131009/@comment-16581186-20161115180606

TimeShade wrote: Uh, those happened on another show, where Earth 2, 3, 19 etc have been established on The Flash. Again, a discussion to add Supergirl may be open AFTER the crossovers. So? Earth 2, 3, and 19 were never established on any of the Arrowverse shows aside from the Flash either. The point is, Supergirl's earth has also been established on the Flash as well, through the cameo in the Flash Welcome to Earth 2, and the result was shown in the Supergirl episode Worlds Finest, and will play a major role again in the 4 night crossover.

And I don't see why you say "again", as if we have had this discussion before. But I'm totally fine with a discussion about this after the crossover (although it's it's more time-efficient to talk about it now since we already know the circumstances of Supergirl joining the episodes).

Rafe Adler wrote: It isn't on here for a reason. It is due to Supergirl existing on an alternate earth. They made an exception with E2 and E3 because Arrowverse characters exist on those worlds. Supergirl's Earth lacks any Arrowverse characters so I assume that is why it isn't on here.

I would love to see the wikis combine, but the admins say no. Again take it up with them as I didn't really understand why. My answer is just why I assume they won't put Supergirl on here. Plus it would be hard to merge the Supergirl Wiki with the Arrowverse Wiki. Well, it seems like you have forgotten that both Harrison Wells and Barry have already established that there are an infinite amount of earths with infinite possibilities of what each earth would turn out to be like, such as one where the Nazi's won World War II, where all of the heroes were villains. Meaning that there are clearly infinite amounts of earths that have no Earth one counterparts, others may have a few.

Take Jesse Quick for example. Where is her Earth one counterpart? Earth one Harrison Wells didn't have a daughter. There's your proof.

Plus, Flash did establish that both Central City and Star Labs do in fact exist on Supergirl's earth, so there is still that common factor between that Earth and Earth 1.

Also, the wiki's don't really need to combine. They can coexist in my opinion.

Kaestal wrote: It's probably the same reason we haven't added the 1990 flash.... Oh, you mean because Grant Gustin's Earth 1 Flash didn't meet him on any earth?

Well guess what, HE DID FOR SUPERGIRL! So I do in fact doubt that is the case.