Board Thread:Arrow discussions/@comment-1783334-20170516181147/@comment-24152851-20170801004306

Cloudtheavenger wrote:

I have a brand new suspect for Vigilante: Walter Steele! It's perfect from the creator's point of view. He hasn't been seen since season 2 or had a significant role in the series unless you count his kidnapping allowing Oliver to discover the truth about Moira's involvement in The Undertaking significant. It's perfect! Plus, their physique is similar. Besides, why the need to retreat if his goggles were destroyed unless Oliver's friends knew him on a personal level? It could also be Curtis' husband. Walter's actually an interesting pick. I could see that working, since he does have the right morals to carry out vigilante duty. Only problem is Vigilante is much more savage than Walter was, something had to have happened to harden him into an extremist. But still, good on ya for coming up with that one.

Paul Holt doesn't really make sense. Vigilante was able to go a round with Prometheus, while Paul is a worse fighter than Curtis. It also makes no sense that Paul would just leave after finding out about Curtis' vigilante duty if he was a vigilante too.