Board Thread:New on Arrowverse Wiki/@comment-807326-20160206040643/@comment-4150178-20160311062817

MadHatterJervisTetch wrote: MakeShift wrote: KalvinEllis wrote: It should not be merged. This wiki should only cover shows that belong to the Arrowverse continuity, or multi-continuity if you will. For example I'm still a bit annoyed by the inclusion of Constantine's entire history. Making a page for the character is obviously a must because he appeared on Arrow, but bringing everything from his show here? Just because it's the same character played by the same actor doesn't necessary mean it's the exact same version of the character from the Constantine show. Arrow's Constanine never mentioned characters like Zed or Papa Midnite, yet we have them here. For all we know this might be a totally different Constantine from the one on that show. If they do a crossover with Lucifer in the future, should we cover that entire show, too? Whatever the case, the Supergirl situation is more peculiar because it's an Arrowverse hero showing up there, not vice versa, but I stick to not merging them. There's no point in my view. Comments like this annoy me. Wendy Mericle, as we've said a million and one times, has confirmed Constantine to be canon within the Arrowverse, hence it's in the exact same universe.

Wendy Mericle was simply asked "One time" if the Constantine that show up on "Arrow" is the same from the "Constantine Show" and she understands it that way that the questioning means "if John Constantine on "Arrow" will be played by Matt Ryan too?" and answerd "yes". And you guys make it like she said: "Yes its 100% confirmed that the Show Constantine is now set to be a part of the Arrowverse in totally!"

this Guy here has a very good point to this.

58.161.201.208 wrote: While the above answer is all well and good, I still think it seems a little much to include Constantine in this wikia. This is a one-off event. The Simpsons and Family Guy wikias have not been join together because of their crossover. Boston Legal had a character appear from Boston Public, they’ve been kept separate. I highly doubt Bones and Sleepy Hollow will have their wikias combined when those shows crossover. NCIS-LA with Hawaii Five-0. I could go on and on....

This is A Detective Munch situation. Richard Belzer has played his Law and Order character on shows like The X-Files, Arrested Development and The Wire. Matt Ryan is in the same boat. He's a character from another show appearing as a one-off. It's just a wink to the audience. Nothing more.

To change this entire wikia is a waste and unnecessary. Constantine the series is not set in the same world as Arrow et al. Flash/Arrow/Legends/Vixen are all part of the same universe and has been planned as such. They're by the same creative team. Constantine is by completely different people.

Finally, even the article used as proof can be seen as ambiguously written as we don't know the direct question asked of Mericle and what the author added afterwards. Similarly, Mericle could have misunderstood the question.

I think it would be best to remove Constantine the series from this wikia.

Also all this can be used to the actual "Supergirl" discusion as well. supergirl is being handled by the people who handle arrowverse