106 Votes in Poll
I kinda preferred Scudder to be honest, with how he tied into Snart's history. Eva's plan was too convoluted and she simply had no reason to antagonize Team Flash.
Let me rephrase. Hands down, I liked Eva more than Grace (or Orlin) but as far as Mirror Master, I liked Eva's usage of her powers specifically in the "finale" but overall story-wise I liked Sam Scudder a bit more because of the aforementioned connection with Snart.
Had they expanded on the mirror powers or the mirrorverse in general back then it would've been great. But better late than never, I guess.
Oh yeah for sure. Scudder had too much unexplored potential with his powers. Eva wins in that department.
Even in terms of motive, she wins over Scudder. She was trapped in a mirror and felt a sense of abandonment, and already you see that the Mirrorverse corrupts people. She basically imposed her feelings about Carver over Barry and Iris's relationship and that's why she had involved these people who otherwise didn't have much of a relation to her goals. (Aside from Iris investigating into the people that would be useful for her plan)
Frankly, both are about the same to me. One Mirror Master had a closer connection to the overall Flash series, ergo has a semi-better plot in my opinion, and the other has far better use of her powers.
While they're fun to watch, neither are really in my top favorite villains. Only thing that is certain was that they're better than the two Cicadas.
Well it's not really fair to say Eva was more developed when she got given half a season, while Scudder was scrapped after one episode (two if you count the future). They could have done a lot with him if they gave him the chance. Esp since he was like a foil to Snart.
Eva just kinda came out of nowhere and suddenly is the Big Bad because of Crisis.
Grace was an actual threat? They literally just waited until she wakes up after knocking her out in 5x21. Ralph literally says "Guys, she's waking up..." while he, Frost & Flash were watching Cisco disarm the meta-bomb-thing. Barry could just cuff her or speed her into the pipeline... But they just watched her like they did Dwyer...
I can't stand Grace
@Arrowverse lover331 same!
@Stryzzar agreed Sam Scudder will and always will be the best mirror master
What do you think?