Ali was a classmate of Mick Rory, Tiffany Harper and Freddy Meyers at Central City High School. Sadly Mick didn't get to go to prom with her due to being sent to a juvenile detention center around that time. When they reunited at the class reunion in 2004, Mick tried to deny who he was but gave in, and he and Ali went to make out. She was killed by Kathy Myers in the school's shop classroom causing Mick to become infuriated. When the Legends managed to stop Kathy in 1989, Ali's fate was undone and she and Mick were making out during the reunion where he showed her "his gun", the Heat Gun, while the rest of the team got a group photo.
This resulted in her and Mick conceiving their daughter, Lita. She tried to contact Mick after learning about her pregnancy but he was in jail again unaware she was impregnated by the present day 2020 Mick who had become a time traveler. She decided not to tell him and went on to raise their daughter by herself although Lita eventually figured out his identity. Rory uses Time Bureau memory wipe device. So Ali and Lita forget that Mick came to their house.
When Ava convinced Mick to incorporate himself into certain points of Lita's life, the first thing they did was bring a crib Mick stole from the Victorian Era to present as a gift to Ali & Lita. Ali was amazed by this and that Mick was helping Ava track down the "worst criminals in history", which hinted to his time traveling adventures while also hiding that fact.
Ali allowed Lita to have a father-daughter weekend with Mick.
Ali disliked Mick Rory for what he did.