- "Jerry Bertinelli, of the eponymous crime family and the last of his kind. The rest of your family is either dead or incarcerated."
- —Cayden James[src]
The Bertinelli crime family was a local crime syndicate in Star City. The family was headed by Frank Bertinelli, before his incarceration, and was subsequently taken over by another family member, Pino Bertinelli, after Frank's death. In 2016, Pino was murdered and the organization had been taken over by Tobias Church. Church's reign was short-lived though, as he was soon killed by Prometheus. After several Bertinellis before him died or were incarcerated, Jerry Bertinelli was forced to take control of the organization. After his death by Ricardo Diaz's hands, the Bertinelli crime family was disbanded. However, it continued to operate under new leadership by the time of the Elseworlds phenomenon.
The Bertinelli crime family, like other crime families, made their fortune through crime actives.
- Frank Bertinelli (leader; deceased)
- Helena Bertinelli (turned against the family)
- Jerry Bertinelli (leader; deceased)
- Pino Bertinelli (leader after Frank's death; deceased)
- Paul Copani (deceased)
- Tobias Church (leader after Pino's death; deceased)
- Nick Salvati (underboss; deceased)
- Emiko Adachi (courier; deceased)
- Star City Docks (formerly)
- Tony D'urso (deceased)
- Anthony Venza (incarcerated)
- Lonnie Machin (formerly; incarcerated)
- Dante (deceased)
- Helena Bertinelli/The Huntress
- Cayden James' criminal cabal
- Oliver Queen/The Arrow
- Chinese Triad