Sometime prior to late 2016, Gay married Charles Eked and the couple had two children. They eventually divorced, but remained on good terms.
In November 2016, Gay was vacuuming the living room and straightening up her children's toys by herself. After finishing, she turned around to see that Prometheus had broken into her home. Screaming in horror, Gay fell backwards onto the ground and attempted to distance herself from the intruder. She begged him to take whatever he wanted but to spare her life because of her children. Prometheus ignored Gay's pleas and hurled a throwing star into her neck, killing her instantly.
Unbeknownst to Gay, she had been targeted solely because her name served as an anagram for the names of criminals on The List.